Bodybuilding, an arena of immense physical prowess and aesthetic perfection, has seen its fair share of controversies and debatable decisions.
While the sport celebrates the pinnacle of human physical achievement, it has also witnessed moments where the athletes’ hard work and dedication were seemingly overlooked or unfairly judged.
This article delves into the top 10 most controversial decisions in bodybuilding history, where many believe the rightful winners were robbed of their glory.
1. The 2001 Mr. Olympia: Ronnie Coleman vs Jay Cutler
In 2001, Ronnie Coleman, who had been holding the Mr. Olympia title for three consecutive years, faced a formidable challenger in Jay Cutler, a relatively new entrant to the Mr. Olympia stage.
Jay Cutler, who had previously placed eighth, came in with a significantly improved physique, challenging the reigning champion.
Critics pointed out that Ronnie Coleman appeared softer than usual, with a noticeable “bubble gut” and a bicep tear just weeks before the competition.
Despite these issues, Ronnie Coleman managed to clinch the title. Many believed Jay Cutler, with his tighter, more defined conditioning and balanced, symmetrical physique, deserved the win.
Adding to the controversy, Jay Cutler faced disqualification the following year and had $60,000 in prize money revoked due to a failed drug test, highlighting the contentious nature of the sport where natural status is often a grey area.
2. The 1972 Mr. Olympia: Arnold Schwarzenegger vs Sergio Oliva
The 1972 Mr. Olympia saw Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sergio Oliva, two titans of the sport, face off in a highly anticipated rematch.
Advertisement
Continue Reading Below
Oliva, who had previously beaten Arnold Schwarzenegger, came in full and thick, with better muscle definition and overall conditioning.
Arnold Schwarzenegger, on the other hand, was criticized for his conditioning and used posing techniques to mask his weaknesses.
Despite Sergio Oliva’s superior physique, Arnold Schwarzenegger was awarded the title. Many, including Oliva, believed the decision was politically motivated to promote Schwarzenegger as the face of bodybuilding.
Advertisement
Continue Reading Below
This contest remains one of the most debated decisions in the sport’s history.
3. The 2007 Mr. Olympia: Jay Cutler vs Victor Martinez
